top of page

Essays with Analysis of Society and Culture

Written by Neha Mazhary

Media On Women's Rights

This research paper’s focus is on the current events happening in Iran with women’s rights as well as a look into the history of similar situations that have occurred in Iran concerning women’s rights and how these situations are dealt with by the media and the general public. The first thing that needs to be discussed is the most recent event which led to ongoing protests in Iran that unified many people. The case of Mahsa Amini’s death after being taken into police custody by the morality police. She was taken into custody for not having her hijab on properly and some witnesses say that she was beaten, later being pronounced dead in the hospital after spending a few days in a coma. However, police deny this allegation, and the general public was quick to jump to one side or another on the debate, which led to protests within the country. According to Brenned Jensen’s article “What is Fueling Iran’s Ongoing Protests?”: On Sept. 16, a 22-year-old Kurdish woman from northwestern Iran named Mahsa Amini (or, Jina Amini, to use her Kurdish name) was visiting Tehran when she was arrested by the so-called morality police. Her alleged crime: improperly wearing her hijab, the mandated head-covering for women. Amini died in police custody at a detention center three days later—her family, citing eyewitnesses accounts, says officers beat her after her arrest, leading to her death. Police reject the allegations, saying Amini died of a heart attack after being taken to a hospital. The event has roiled the nation, sparking some of the most widespread and violent protests since the founding of the Islamic Republic in 1979. Women and girls have often been in the forefront of demonstrations, burning their hijabs amid calls for freedom. Humanitarian organizations estimate the unrest has resulted in the deaths of 200 people, including perhaps as many as two-dozen children. The government, meanwhile, says 20 members of its security forces have been killed.” (WHAT'S FUELING IRAN'S ONGOING PROTESTS? By Brennen Jensen). Through this article the audience gets some insight on what event caused the protest to become prominent and for people all over the country to unite for a purpose. People in Iran as well as all over the world joined together to show their feelings about the events that occurred in Iran. According to Alena Kuzub’s article “Protests in Iran Will Continue as Long as Demands of People Remain Unsatisfied, Northeastern Experts Say” where the author talked about people’s reactions and reasons for starting the protests they talk about the uproar after the event that occurred as well as why they believe the protest became so known universally. “Today’s protests are actually the cumulative effect of years, if not decades of grievances of various structures of Iranian society against the regime,” Moghadam said. Since Sept. 17 when the protests started, they have spread across the country, social classes, religious groups and genders, despite the violent crackdown of the government. “The very fact that there has been so much solidarity with this one young woman, a Sunni, really tells you a lot about the political maturity of Iranian society. But it also shows the depth and the extent of the grievances towards the Islamic regime,” Moghadam said. (“Protests in Iran Will Continue as Long as Demands of People Remain Unsatisfied, Northeastern Experts Say” By Alena Kuzub). Similar protests have been going on for years with women protesting the clothing they are forced to wear as well as the hijabs. Women have been protesting the regulations placed on them and have been taken into police custody each time, leading to protests to spark whenever the events occur. Through social media, the issues gain a bigger platform as the news is able to be spread worldwide. Through media and especially social media in the present day, people all over the world are able to see the events occurring in different countries and share their opinions about such events. Years and years of unrest within a collection of people will reach its boiling point after events like what happened to Amini occur, causing people to become more involved in the fight for what they think is right. Sometimes leading to changes being made as more and more people become aware of the unrest occurring in the different countries that are not their own. In the article “Soapboxes and Stealth on Revolution Street: Revisiting the Question of 'Freedom' in Iran's Hijab Protests” by Marie B. Ranjbar: “ On December 26, 2017, 31-year old Vida Movahedi climbed atop a utility box located on Enghelab (Revolution) Street, one of Tehran’s busiest streets. She wore jeans and a sweater instead of the requisite outer garment (e.g. manteau) that women in Iran must wear in public space. She also removed the white scarf from her head, a criminal offense since 1983 under Iran’s Islamic Penal code. Tying her scarf to a stick, she silently waved it like a flag from her elevated platform for almost an hour, while passersby took pictures and posted her image on social media. Following the protest, Movahedi was detained for nearly a month, prompting a national social media campaign to pressure Iranian authorities to release her. As Movahedi’s identity had not been released to the public, she was instead referred to as the ‘girl from Revolution Street,’ with concerned Iranians tweeting # رتخد _ نابایخ _ بالقنا _ تساجک (“Where is the Girl from Revolution Street?”) and the English-language hashtag #Where_Is_She. Movahedi was released on bail in late January 2018, only to be arrested several months later following a second demonstration. On October 23, 2018, Movahedi again waved her veil from a stick with an armful of balloons, while standing on top of a dome in Enghelab (Revolution) Square, one of Tehran’s largest roundabouts. Movahedi was subsequently sentenced to one year in prison on charges of “encouraging corruption and prostitution to the public” for unveiling in public space” (Soapboxes and Stealth on Revolution Street: Revisiting the Question of 'Freedom' in Iran's Hijab Protests by Marie A. Ranjbar) The rise of social media in the past few years has given an outlet for people to share their stories and get others involved in a fast and easy way. It is a way to bring things like injustice and wrongdoings of others to attention, but it can also cause biases towards one side or the other. In the case of the most recent incident in Iran, it had caused an uproar with people worldwide, reaching a greater audience and getting many people talking about the situation and finding ways to help and spread the word further. Videos were being posted online of celebrities talking about what happened and spreading information to their fans to bring attention to the situation. In the case of what happened to Vida Movahedi, as well as what happened to Mahsa Amini, people had begun to spread hashtags across media platforms, making it their responsibility to spread the word and help the women who had been wronged. When the incidents first occurred, information was being spread like wildfire to inform as many people as possible to bring the situations to light. 

Women in Islam

There are many things to mention when talking about the role of women in Islam. Specifically, when talking about their role and rights when it comes to things such as marriage, divorce and even adoption. There are many rules in Islam dealing with women rights and actions towards women, a lot of which seem to work in their favor. For example, when looking at certain stories in the Quran, many different kinds of women are seen in varying circumstances. However, many of the women who were shown to have faith and devotion were given help in some way if they prayed. Even in the early days when the religion was not as well established, whenever women prayed and devoted themselves, they were well taken care of, like Maryam, who was given resources and ways to take care of herself. Through the stories in the Quran, there are many details and saying to be analyzed when women’s rights are concerned. In the cases of marriage, adoption and divorce, however, there are many things that need to be covered; from certain rules and restriction to things that are a bit confusing or do not make sense. The laws vary in many ways for each topic, some in the favor of women and some not so much when looked at closely. To start, there is the topic of marriage in Islam and what that exactly are the conditions and rules for marriage. For example, there are many verses in the Quran talking about who you can and cannot marry as well as some general criteria for how a spouse should be. Specifically, there are many conditions explaining that a person cannot marry certain people like polytheistic people until they believe in Islam (Al-Baqarah, verse 221). Another rule is one that relates to remarrying somebody and what rules to follow when doing so. In Islam there is a grace period when it comes to remarriage, which must be passed before a person can remarry. If talking about remarriage in specific, something that must be discussed is the concept of a couple separating but then marrying each other again. In the Quran, it is stated that if a couple were to decide that they want to remarry, as long as they both agree, nobody can stop them from doing so; however, they must wait through the grace period to remarry(Quran, Al-Baqarah verse 232). However, if said couple were to divorce three times, they are not suitable to marry each other once again until the woman finds another husband first (Al-Baqarah). Conditions relating to marriage and divorce always talk about a grace period which is known and iddat and lasts for a certain amount of time, however, it also states that if a man were to divorce a woman without touching her, then iddat does not apply for either in that case (Al-Ahzab, verse 29). These are a few conditions that talk about both marriage and divorce in the Quran, however, there are a lot more not mentioned so far. These rules seem prominent in specific situations of marriage and divorce, though some others are not as specific. An example of this are all the rules that emphasize that if a person has faith, then they must also marry somebody who believe in the religion as well and both husband and wife must not have had intercourse out of marriage before the marriage contract is to take effect. In Islam it is also not permissible to marry a woman without the permission of her family or the people around her. Another condition is that the man must pay a dowry to the woman he is to marry and when they are to divorce, under certain conditions, the woman is to return the dowry to the man if they are to be divorced. The way divorce worked in Islam has changed a lot as times have changed and developed and there are cases of different outcomes to divorce depending on the circumstances. Even Islam had changed the way divorce works when it was first established. For in the beginnings of Islam, there were tribes and the women in those tribes had very low social statues and were basically treated as slaves, however, Islam pushed more towards equality between men and women so the rules regarding divorce were changed. There are some instances when the husband had given a dowry to the wife and sometimes if they divorce, the wife will have to give the dowry back to him as a result of the divorce. According to the Quran, the husband cannot send her away from the house as that is her house as well and he is to still provide her with resources until she can do so herself. Another law pertaining to divorce is that a man cannot divorce a woman if she is pregnant or breastfeeding, the husband is to still provide for the mother and child until she stops breastfeeding the child before he can divorce her. Also, in order for the divorce to be confirmed, there need to be witnesses when the divorce happens. As stated in the Quran, there need to be at least to people present when it happens, specifying that it must be the husband’s two most trusted men. (Surat Talak) Up until a few years ago, there used to be a law that let men divorce women easily just by saying the word three times. In many Muslim countries if a man said the word “talak”, which is the Arabic word for divorce then their marriage would be dissolved, it did not even need to be spoken out loud to the person as men were able to do it over the phone or text. However, many women spoke out against this rule as they were getting kicked out of their houses just by their husbands divorcing them and saying the word talak three times. The rule was overruled in almost every country over the years as it went against women’s rights to equality in the countries with India being one of the last countries to erase the rule. This law had brought up many movements among women in the countries as they argued that it was not fair to them that their husbands could so easily divorce them and the government agreed to change it after seeing the movements of the women effected. However, the men argued that the changing of the law would be unfair to them but the law was still erased as the government sided with the women in this situation in the name of equality. Moving on to the topic of adoption and what the term means in Islam. Now, the concept of adoption is not allowed in Islam because adoption means that the child’s last name is being changed. In Islam, it is forbidden to change a child’s surname, instead it is permissible to foster children as it means they can still be cared for and taken in by a family but their surname will not be changed. When looking specifically and younger children, who were adopted, it is said that a child must be suckled by the mother a number of times before they can be considered their child. This same rule applies in the case of children who are breastfed by the same mother, they must be fed a number of times before being considered milk siblings. Throughout the history of Islam there have been many cases of fostering as told in the Quran such as Mussa, Maryam, and, Mohammad however each story varies in the events that take place in it. Briefly looking at each story, there are many things to dissect in the ones mentioned above. To start with, there is the story of Mussa, a child born during a time where baby boys were being killed by the order of the Pharaoh. In this story there is a desperate mother who wishes to save her son from being killed so she prays and has her prayers answered as he is found by the Pharaoh’s wife who chooses to raise him. The mother was instructed to care for him for as long as she could and when she is scared for him, she will send him down the river in a basket. In the end Mussa is found by the Pharaoh’s wife and she convinces her husband to let her raise him. The mother was still able to be reunited with her son, though, because Mussa would reject all other wet nurses until his sister recommended his mother to the Pharaoh’s wife. This story shows how Mussa’s mother’s faith led her to reuniting with her son even after she had sent him away for his own safety. In these circumstances, Mussa was found by the Pharaoh’s wife and taken in, but it was still considered fostering as she did not nurse him herself (Surat Taha and Surat Al-Qasas). Next, talking about the story of Muhammad, who was raised by many people throughout his life. Throughout his life he was raised by many people, from his grandfather to his uncle from a young age until he reached adulthood. Along with this though, he also had many milk mothers, since he was an orphaned child there would be wet nurses who would feed him when he was a baby. During those times there used to be a lot of children in need of wet nurses so the wet nurses who would feed the children would also get paid for doing so. In the story of Maryam, she is raised by her aunt’s husband, who takes her in and cares for her. According to Surat Al Imran, Maryam was well provided for whenever Zakarya would visit her. She had all the resources she would need and whenever he would ask where it all came from, she would answer that it was all because of her prayers to Allah and her faith that she received all the things she had. Moving onto the final topic of the paper, there is the concept of inheritance and what that entails for women in Islam. Some background information needed in order to understand Islam where it concerns inheritance. First if Rizq, which essentially translated wealth. In Islam, it is believed that wealth should be shared with others: whether that means with other family members, or people in need like charities or people in poverty struck places. The act of giving to people in need is known as zakat and it is something many Muslims will do much of in their lifetimes. Muslims have found many ways to give zakat to others: Muslims who are not able to fast will give zakat to feed the people who do not have easy access to food instead. Every Mosque, which is the Muslim place of worship, have a certain area where people are able to pass by and drop some money to give as zakat. During Eid, a Muslim religious holiday, there are many families who will start donation boxes during family celebrations for Eid. Through the process of gathering donations during Eid, every year, people are able to gather hundreds of non-profit organizations to help the poem, such as non-profit hospitals and such. However, inheritance and what it means to the family members inheriting the things, there are some different things to see. Now, when it comes to discussing what inheritance means to women, it means that some information is needed for how much a person can inherit and the reason for that amount. The amount of inheritance given to the beneficiary depends on how many beneficiaries there are. For example, a person cannot give all of their wealth to a singular person when other beneficiaries exist, it is simply not allowed in Islam. The beneficiaries of a person usually contain the person’s spouse, children and parents; all of whom are entitled to a portion of the inheritance. Although, it is widely known that, while women are entitled to the inheritances, they will receive less money is there is also a male present. In the case of sons and daughters, the daughters inherit half as much as the sons do. However, the reason for that is that the men tend to be the breadwinners of the family, therefore they receive a bigger share in order to help them with the family. Along with these rules, some other general knowledge to know is that the inheritance cannot be distributed if the person deceased person had a debt to pay. The debt must be paid before the inheritance is given to the beneficiary. Another rule is that Prophets, cannot inherit wealth as a beneficiary but they can inherit knowledge from the person they are the beneficiary for. To summarize everything discussed above, the laws in Islam and how they affect women are quite different for each and every topic discussed. From marriage, to inheritance some laws do work in the favor of women, though, especially when talking about resources and such because a lot of the times the man is expected to provide for the family. In order to marry a woman, the man must provide a dowry for her most of the time, usually resources or money. Even when they are divorced, the woman is still able to live in the same house, and the man is still expected to provide her with resources until she can take care of herself; she cannot be outcasted from the house right after the divorce. These are some examples as to how the laws of Islam say to treat women; the women are able to be treated mostly like equals to the men in Islam. Of course, there are some differences, though. However, there are also many laws that work in the favor of women when it comes to Islam, such as the reasons stated above.

bottom of page